How to Defend a Contested Will

When a will is challenged, executors and beneficiaries need to understand their position and respond correctly. We advise executors on their duties while a claim is outstanding, and act for beneficiaries whose inheritance is at risk.

Where possible, we seek to resolve disputes through negotiation or mediation before court proceedings become necessary.

Who Can Defend a Will?

Executors and beneficiaries are most often involved in defending a will. An executor's role is to obtain a grant and administer the estate in accordance with the will. Where the validity of the will is challenged, the executor will usually defend it if there is good reason to believe it is valid. In a claim under the Inheritance Act 1975, the executor should normally remain neutral and leave the beneficiaries to argue the merits.

We act for both executors and beneficiaries, advising on their legal position and protecting their interests.

Steps to Take When a Will Is Challenged

• Seek early legal advice: Quick action helps prevent procedural errors and delays.
• Gather key evidence: Obtain copies of the will, any previous versions, witness statements, and solicitor notes from its preparation.
• Check for proper execution: Confirm that the will meets legal signing and witnessing requirements.
• Assess the claimant’s grounds: Understand the legal basis of the challenge to prepare an appropriate defence.
• Attempt early resolution: Mediation and negotiation can often save time and cost while preserving family relationships.

Evidence That Can Strengthen Your Case

Good evidence is key to defending a contested will. Useful materials include:

• Statements from witnesses who observed the will signing.
• Correspondence or solicitor file notes confirming instructions were freely given.
• Medical reports verifying the testator’s mental capacity.
• Earlier wills showing a consistent pattern of intention.

We can help you compile and present this evidence effectively to strengthen your defence.

Defending Against Specific Claims

Different types of challenges require tailored strategies:

• Undue Influence: Show the will was made freely and independently, often supported by solicitor or witness evidence.
• Lack of Capacity: Use medical records and professional testimony to demonstrate full understanding.
• Fraud or Forgery: Provide authentication evidence or expert handwriting reports.
• Inheritance Act Claims: Argue that reasonable provision was made or that the claimant’s financial position does not justify additional support.

Mediation and Settlement Options

Court proceedings are expensive and can take many months. Mediation is private, usually quicker, and allows the parties to agree terms rather than have them imposed, and the court expects parties to consider it. We represent clients in mediation and in negotiations aimed at a settlement that respects the will as far as possible.

Court Proceedings and Representation

If settlement cannot be reached, we act for you in court proceedings. We prepare your defence thoroughly, keep costs under review, and advise you at each stage on whether settlement remains the better course.

Next Steps

If you are an executor or beneficiary and a will has been challenged, contact us. We will review the claim, advise you on your position and options, and explain the likely costs.

More Will Disputes services